【科技論文寫作】05-論文投稿流程與常見問題

第五講

英文論文投稿流程與常見問題11.目

期刊的選擇2文章未送審直接被拒稿的常見理由：1.

沒有通過雜志的技術(shù)審查；2.

不屬于期刊范圍（Aims

andScope）；3.

研究不完整；4.

試驗設(shè)計存在缺陷：如對照組、樣本量、數(shù)據(jù)處理、5.

試驗數(shù)據(jù)并不足以支撐研究結(jié)果；6.

缺乏；7.

文章難以理解；8.

文章缺乏研究意義。Peter

Thrower

,Eight

reasonsIrejected

your

article31.目標(biāo)期刊的選擇

學(xué)科與影響力

影響因子

(Impact

Fa

t

,IF)

審稿平均周期

主編水平

版面費41.1學(xué)科與影響力SJR（

ScientificJournalRanking）51.2影響因子

影響因子是湯森路透（Thomson

Reuters）出品的期刊引證報告（Journal

Citation

Reports，JCR）中的一項數(shù)據(jù)。

即某期刊前兩年發(fā)表的論文在該報告年份（JCR

yea

）中被引用總次數(shù)除以該期刊在這兩年內(nèi)發(fā)表的論文總數(shù)。這是一個國際上通行的期刊評價指標(biāo)。61.3審稿平均周期

審稿周期：一般情況1-3個月；小修：1-

返修的時間修：一般至

周

復(fù)審周期：一般1周-1個月不等；71.3審稿平均周期Editorial

EvaluationTimelineAll

submissions

areinitially

evaluatedindepthbythe

scientiiceditors.

Pap

rsthat

arenot

deemedbythe

editorsto

bestrong

candidatesfor

publicationwill

be

etu

ned

totheauthorswithoutdetailed

review,

typicall

within

3–5days

Otherwise

man

scriptswill

besentto

reviewers

whohaveagadvanceto

as

essthepaperrapi

l

y.

Theeditorswill

makeeveryeffort

to

ac

de

ons

onthese

p

perswithin

3–4weeks

ofthesubmission

ate.

I

revisions

reaconditionofpublicatio

,

editorswill

carefullyevaluatethe

revitheimportantcmmensand,sto

beaddre

sed.r

possible,will

provideguidance

onnerallyallow

2monthsfor

revisionsandconsideronlyonerevisedversionofthepaper.

Evaluations

ofconceptualadvanceandsignificance

remade

asedontheliterature

available

onthedayof

thefinaldecision,notthe

dayofsubmission.

Acceptedpaperswill

bepublished

inprintwithin

3monthsofacceptance

and,inmost

cases,

earlierinprintoronline.

Anymajorchangesafter

acceptancearesubjectto

reviewandmaydelaypublication.81.4主編水平1.

不同主編的處理稿件風(fēng)格2.選擇審稿人是否專業(yè)3.選擇審稿人數(shù)量91.5版面費

按照頁數(shù)；

彩圖；

印刷本；

Openaccess102.根據(jù)期刊要求調(diào)整文章112.根據(jù)期刊要求調(diào)整文章

2.1

Guidelines根據(jù)期刊要求確定文章體裁與長度期刊范圍適當(dāng)調(diào)整摘要與關(guān)鍵詞圖文格式要求（包括Tittlepage）字體種類、

小文章格文章整體結(jié)構(gòu)、版塊其它特殊要求，如單位，縮寫等122.2期刊的審查重點①

文章是否符合期刊范圍、文章格式、文章長度；②

文章創(chuàng)新性，重要程度（高IF期刊）；③

文章內(nèi)容：摘要，關(guān)鍵詞，參考文獻(xiàn)（時效性要好，自引率不要太高），圖表（字體一致性

好，美觀程度要高，最重要?。?，結(jié)論④

抄襲與主編在期刊的后臺界面可以看到作者的投稿歷史，里邊有一些備注要點；同步有與數(shù)據(jù)庫比對的結(jié)果與細(xì)節(jié)，主編會據(jù)此判斷稿件是否有剽竊的行為。13Check

list

數(shù)據(jù)是否支持文章結(jié)論？

結(jié)果是否重要和有趣？

是否存在倫理問題？

文章是否具有原創(chuàng)性？

動機(jī)是否

？

是否存在一些缺陷和錯誤？

是否有需要增加的內(nèi)容？

描述是否清晰？143.其他材料153.其他材料3.1稿件作者信息3.2投稿信（

Coverletter

）3.3推薦審稿人3.4特殊

料：highlights、graphic

abstract、結(jié)構(gòu)式摘要等163.1稿件作者信息a.

作者順序c.單位信息注意作者第一單位d.致謝部分b.通訊作者173.2投稿信（Cover

letter）Coverletter：投稿信的首要目的是讓編輯了解論文

創(chuàng)新點，為什么要投稿給該期刊。投稿信結(jié)構(gòu)?文章梗?版權(quán)聲明?學(xué)術(shù)道德18Dear

Editors:We

wouldliketosubmittheenclosed

manuscript

entitled“Paper

Title”,whichwewishtobeconsideredforpublicationin“JournalName”.Noconflictofinterestexitsinthesubmissionofthismanuscript,andmanuscript

isapprovedbyallauthorsforpublication.I

wouldliketodeclare

onbehalfofmy

co-authors

thattheworkdescribedwas

origi

al

research

thathas

notbeenpublishedpreviously,andnotunderconsiderationfor

publicationelsewher

inwh

leor

npart.

Alltheauthorslistedhave

approvedthemanuscript

thatisenclosed.聲明對文章進(jìn)行簡短的介紹；Inthiswork,weevaluated

….Ihopethispaperiss

itablefName”.Tips：We

deeplyappreciate

your

nsideraourmanu

ipt

an

welookn’thesi

te

ocontaardtoreceivingco

ments

from

thedress

below.

突出文章的創(chuàng)新性和reviewers.

Ifyouhave

an重要性；Thankyouandbest

regards.Yours

sincerely,

不要太長，應(yīng)簡潔明了?！痢痢痢痢痢罜orrespondingauthor:Name:

×××E-mail:××××@××××193.3推薦審稿人三種審稿方式A.

Double-blind

revi

wB.

Single

blindreviewC.

Openreview203.3推薦審稿人推薦3-5個審稿人（單位，郵箱，推薦理由）21如何選擇審稿人【主編視角】選擇審稿人（避免利益相關(guān)）來源：1）作者推薦；2）審稿人庫；3）其他審稿人推薦；4）編輯自己選擇?！咀髡咭暯恰靠蛇x的范）讀過/引用

獻(xiàn)里的作者；2）會議或?qū)W術(shù)交流認(rèn)識的相關(guān)學(xué)者；3）同校的學(xué)者；4）前同事，導(dǎo)師，學(xué)生等。不推薦的范圍：1）與作者的研究有利益沖突的學(xué)者；2）投稿文章的作者。223.4特殊材料

Highlights：

3-5條，每條包括空格在內(nèi)不超過85個字符；Ref.

/10.1016/j.gene.2016.07.05823Graphic

Abstract24DOI:/10.1016/j.cell.2016.09.056結(jié)構(gòu)式摘要ABSTRACT

目的

方法果

結(jié)論Ref.

/pmc/articles/PMC4704659/254.正式投稿264.正式投稿投稿系統(tǒng)1

23

4

5陸

上傳

確認(rèn)

等待注冊27OriginalArticle投稿流程ReviewShortCommunicationOpinion28(1)Select

Article

Type29(2)Enter

Title30(3)Add/Edit/Remove

Authors31(4)SubmitAbstract32(5)Enter

Keywords33(6)Select

Classifications（有的雜志需要）431534(7)Enter

Comments35(8)Enter

Highlights（有的雜志需要）一般要求：1、包括3-5點；2、每點的字

數(shù)（包括空格、單詞和標(biāo)點符號），不超過85；3、只介紹文中最重要的結(jié)果。36(9)SuggestReviewers

（有的雜志需要）37(10)Request

anEditor（有的雜志需要）38(11)Additional

Information39(12)Attach

Files40(13)

完成415.審稿流程425.審稿流程5.1

期刊主編預(yù)審與技術(shù)審查

內(nèi)容是否符合期刊的刊載范圍

文章格

是否滿足期刊

求

語言是否達(dá)到基本要求43送審1號審稿人2號審稿人主編審稿意見Negative審稿意見Positive3號審稿人決定性意見446.審

意見與答復(fù)456.1回復(fù)流程466.2不同類型的審稿意見（1）未送審直接拒稿；（2）送審后拒稿（或

可以修改之后重新投稿）；（3）經(jīng)過審稿人審閱并提出有條件的接收(大修或小修)；（4）經(jīng)

審稿人審閱并直接接收。47（1-1）未送審直接拒稿-僅因為語言問題48（1-2）未送審直接拒稿-不符合期刊主題49（1-3）未送審直接拒稿-其他50（2）送審后拒稿-文章質(zhì)量問題51（3-1）送審后建議修改-有內(nèi)容和語言問題52（3-2）送審后建議修改-只需要修改內(nèi)容53（3-3）送審后建議修改-返修后被提出語言問題54（3-4）送審后建議修改-審稿人意見不一致Reviewer

#1Reviewer

#255（4）送審后文章直接接收566.3回復(fù)信的注意事項

禮貌：回復(fù)的內(nèi)容很可能回到審稿人的手中；

回復(fù)信要將審稿人的問

逐點回復(fù)；

提供的返修稿中要高亮出改動的部分；

并不是所有的建議都采納，但是需要對沒有采納的建議給出合理的解釋（禮貌?。?7回復(fù)信（respond

letter）ResponsetoReviewer

Comments#Reviewer

1<Comments>….Question1:…..Reply:…..審稿人Question2:..的回復(fù).#Reviewer

2<Comments>….Question1:…..Reply:…..….58回復(fù)信（respond

letter）ResponsetoReviewer

Comments#Reviewer

1<Comments>ABCD-D-15-00126

presentsinterestingandstimulatingresult

showing….Thescalewas

well

haracte

ed

byMM,NN,andMNforvariousWWand

withvarious

rameters.

A

plausib

explanation

asbee

offeredinthecontext

ofXX,influenced

by

YYand,

osomeZ.

Intheend,

thiss

ouldoffera

eaningful

ontributiontotheunderstandingof….Question

1:The

aper

i

ied

ofandnot

pendthent

oftheproposed

echanrough

proofre

ng(atleast30g

ammaticalmistakes).Itisillogicaltoconduct

extensmitapolishedproduct.Inthe

endit

isverydistractingtothReply:

Thanks

verymuchforthesuggestionsfromthereviewer.Before

resubmission,thismanuscript

waseditedandchecke

byaprofess

nal

Englisheditingcompany

(),whichdealswithEnglisheditingfor

non-native

nglishresearchers.

We

hope

thatourmanuscriptmeetsyourrequirements

forpublicationnow.

Alltheamendments

arehighlighted

inredintherevisedmanuscript.Intheendofthemanuscript,

werevisedthisparagraph

andmovedthisparagraph

tothediscussionpart(Page19,Paragraph

3).59回復(fù)信（respond

letter）Question

2:Thepresentationmaybemore

insightfulandself-consistentifthebargr

phapproachwerereplacedbyconventionalscatterdiagramsforfigures1,2,7,8,11,12.

Thesewouldneed

naverageXXfortheY

Y,whichisnotclearly

specified.

Ataminimum,figures1,2visuallysu

gestZZ

whentheo

positeistrue.Reply:

Thanks

verymuchforthesuggestionsfromthereviewer.

We

revis

d

Figure1andFigure2assuggestedbythereviewer

andcorrected

somemistakesin

igure7,8,11

and1….We

hopeisedversionof

emaowacceptable

forpublication

inyour

journal.Atlast,thanks

erymuchforallofyo

rhelpandyourtime.Bestwishes,Yours

sincerely,XXXX607.稿件最終“命運”617.1接收之后

請盡量配合出版社的要求盡快將文章正式發(fā)表上線（填寫表格，修改文章等）62Proof

readingDearD

r.

XXXX,You

cansaveandreturnto

ourarticle

atanytimeduringthecorrectionprocess.Onc

youmakecorrectionsandhittheSUBM

buttonyoucalongermakefurtherThankyouforpublishing

with‘Journal

ofXXXX’.We

arepleased

toinform

youthatthe

proofforyourupcoming

publicationisreadyfor

reviewviathelinkbelow.

Yo

uwill

find

instructions

o

th

rtcorre

tions

Whenmultipleau

horsareexpectedtomakecorrections,itimportanttonotethateac

ersondoesnotclicktheS

MIT

buttonatthe

ndoftheircorrections.pageonhowtomakecorrectionsdi

ectly

northrough

PDF.enWe

willdoeverything

possibletogetyourarticlepublishedq

icklyandaccurately.Thesoonerwehearfromyou,thesooneryourcorrectedarticlewillbepublishedonline.

You

canexpectyourcorrectedprooftoappearonlineinwithinaweekafterwereceiveyourcorrections.http://live.elsevieXXXXXX.com/a

t

orproWe

verymuchlookforwardtoyourresponse.We

askyoutochecktha

youaresatisfied

withtheaccuracyofthetypesett

ng,copy-editing,

andwiththecompletenessand

correctness

ofthe

text,

tablesandfigures.

To

assist

youwiththis,

copy-editingchanges

havebeenhighlighted.Yours

sincerely,Elseviere-mail:XXXX@XXXX.com3文章授權(quán)CHECK

YOUR

CONTACT

DETAILS:Pleasecheck

thatyourdetailslisted

belowarecorrectsowecancontactyou

if

needed:Dear

XXXX,Name:XXXThank

you

forchoosing

topublishin

JournalXXXX.

Pleasereadthise-mail

carefullyasitcontainsimportantinformation.Add:

XXXXPhone:XXXXFax:

notavailableE

mail:

XXXX

XFINALIZE

PUBLISHING

YOUR

ARTICLE:We

workhardtopublishoura

thors’

articles

lineasqu

lyand

efficiently

aspossi

e,thereforeprocessin

ofyourYOUR

REFERENCE

NUMBER:Lastly,

tohelp

sprovideyou

withthebestservice,pleasemakeaoteofyour

article's

referencenumber

ABDCFE

XXXX

and

quotei

inallofyour

messagestous.acceptedmanuscriptforpublensurethatwepubliswishes,pleasenow

cosalread

egu

.

Toaccordance

withyoheformsfoundhereThank

you

foryourcooperation.Pleasecontactusifyou

have

anyquestions./aut

orforms

ad8934jdjfds9838Ifthislinkdoesnotwork,

pleasecopy

theentireURL

(notingthat

itmayrunontoasecondlineinthismessage)intoyourbrowser.Kindregards,XXXXXX465Available

onlineDear

Dr.

XXXX,Thisversion

willbe

replaced

by

the

finalversionassoon

asthisisavailable.We

arepleased

to

informyou

thatyour

acceptedmanuscript(unformatted

and

unedited

PDF)

isnowavailableonline

at:Your

articlec

n

alreadybecit

dusing

the

yearof

onlineavailabilityand

th

DOIasfo

ow

Author(s),ArticleTitle,Journal(Year),

OI./10.1616/abd39dkgj2Oncethefu

bibliographic

details

(including

volumeandpage

numbe

ng)

for

citation

purposesare

available,youYou

mightlike

to

bookmark

ispermanen

URLto

y

urarticle.Pleasenote

ac

ssto

h

lltext

o

hisarticlewill

willbealerte

by

e-mail.depend

on

your

p