版權(quán)說明:本文檔由用戶提供并上傳,收益歸屬內(nèi)容提供方,若內(nèi)容存在侵權(quán),請進行舉報或認(rèn)領(lǐng)
文檔簡介
1、g r e a w a m o d e l essaystopics in the following list may appear in your actual test. youshould become familiar with this list before you take the gre-awatest. remember that when you take the test you will not have achoice of topics. you must write only on the topic that is assigned toyou.the poo
2、l of issue topicspresent your perspective on the issue below, using relevant reasons and/or examplesto support your views.issue 1we can usually learn much more from people whose views we share than from people whoseviews contradict our own.; disagreement can cause stress and inhibit learning.do we l
3、earn more from people whose ideas we share in common than from those whoseideas contradict ours? the speaker daims so, for the reason that disagreement can causestress and inhibit learning. i concede that undue discord can impede learning. otherwise, inmy view we learn far more from discourse and de
4、bate with those whose ideas we oppose thanfrom people whose ideas are in accord with our own.admittedly, under some circumstances disagreement with others can be counterproductiveto learning. for supporting examples one need look no further than a television set. on todaystypical television or radio
5、 talk show, disagreement usually manifests itself in meaninglessrhetorical bouts and shouting matches, during which opponents vie to have their own messageheard, but have little interest either in finding common ground with or in acknowledging themerits of the opponents viewpoint. understandably, ne
6、ither the combatants nor the viewerslearn anything meaningful. in fact, these battles only serve to reinforce the predispositions andbiases of all concerned. the end result is that learning is impeded.disagreement can also inhibit learning when two opponents disagree on fundamentalassumptions needed
7、 for meaningful discourse and debate. for example, a student ofpaleontology learns little about the evolution of an animal species under current study bydebating with an individual whose religious belief system precludes the possibility of evolutionto begin with. and, economics and finance students
8、learn little about the dynamics of alaissez-faire system by debating with a socialist whose view is that a centrv2ized power shouldcontrol all economic activity.aside from the foregoing two provisos, however, i fundamentally disagree with the speakersclaim. assuming common ground between two rationa
9、l and reasonable opponents willing todebate on intellectual merits, both opponents stand to gain much from that debate. indeed it isprimarily through such debate that human knowledge advances, whether at the personal,community, or global level.at the personal level, by listening to their parents rat
10、ionale for their seemingly oppressiverules and policies teenagers can learn how certain behaviors naturally carry certainundesirable consequences. at the same time, by listening to their teenagers concerns aboutautonomy and about peer pressures parents can learn the valuable lesson that effectivepar
11、enting and control are two different things. at the community level, through dispassionatedialogue an environmental activist can come to understand the legitimate economic concernsof those whose jobs depend on the continued profitable operation of a factory. conversely, thelatter might stand to lear
12、n much about the potential public health price to be paid by ensuringjob growth and a low unemployment rate. finally, at the global level, two nations with opposingpolitical or economic interests can reach mutually beneficial agreements by striving tounderstand the others legitimate concerns for its
13、 national security, its political sovereignty, thestability of its economy and currency, and so forth.in sum, unless two opponents in a debate are each willing to play on the same field and bythe same rules, i concede that disagreement can impede learning. otherwise, reasoneddiscourse and debate bet
14、ween people with opposing viewpoints is the very foundation uponwhich human knowledge advances. accordingly, on balance the speaker is fundamentallycorrect.issue 2no field of study can advance significantly unless outsiders bring their knowledge andexperience to that field of study.i strongly agree
15、with the assertion that significant advances in knowledge require expertisefrom various fields. the world around us presents a seamless web of physical andanthropogenic forces, which interact in ways that can be understood only in the context of avariety of disciplines. two examples that aptly illus
16、trate this point involve the fields of culturalanthropology and astronomy.consider how a cultural anthropologists knowledge about an ancient civilization isenhanced not only by the expertise of the archeologist-who unearths the evidence-butultimately by the expertise of biochemists, geologists, ling
17、uists, and even astronomers. byanalyzing the hair, nails, blood and bones of mummified bodies, biochemists and forensicscientists can determine the life expectancy, general well-being, and common causes of deathof the population. these experts can also ensure the proper preservation of evidence foun
18、d atthe archeological site. a geologist can help identify the source and age of the materials usedfor tools, weapons, and structures-thereby enabling the anthropologist to extrapolate aboutthe civilizations economy, trades and work habits, life styles, extent of travel and mobility, andso forth. lin
19、guists are needed to interpret hieroglyphics and extrapolate from found fragmentsof writings. and an astronomer can help explain the layout of an ancient city as well as thedesign, structure and position of monuments, tombs, and temples-since ancients often lookedto the stars for guidance in buildin
20、g cities and structures.an even more striking example of how expertise in diverse fields is needed to advanceknowledge involves the area of astronomy and space exploration. significant advancements inour knowledge of the solar system and the universe require increasingly keen tools forobservation an
21、d measurement. telescope technology and the measurement of celestialdistances, masses, volumes, and so forth, are the domain of astrophysicists.these advances also require increasingly sophisticated means of exploration. manned andunmanned exploratory probes are designed by mechanical, electrical, a
22、nd computerengineers. and to build and enable these technologies requires the acumen and savvy ofbusiness leaders, managers, and politicians. even diplomats might play a role-insofar asmajor space projects require intemafional cooperative efforts among the worlds scientists andgovernments. and ultim
23、ately it is our philosophers whose expertise helps provide meaning towhat we learn about our universe.in sum, no area ofinteuectual inquiry operates in a vacuum. because the sciences areinextricably related, to advance our knowledge in any one area we must understand theinterplay among them all. mor
24、eover, it is our non-scienfists who make possible the science,and who bring meaning to what we learn from it.issue 3a nation should require all its students to study the same national curriculum until they entercollege rather than allow schools in different parts of the nation to determine which aca
25、demiccourses to offer.the speaker would prefer a national curriculum for all children up until college instead ofallowing schools in different regions the freedom to decide on their own curricula. i agreeinsofar as some common core curriculum would serve useful purposes for any nation(國民). at the sa
26、me time, however, individual states and communities should have some freedom toaugment any such curriculum as they see fit; otherwise, a nations educational system mightdefeat its own purposes in the long tern.a national core curriculum would be beneficial to a nation in a number of respects. first
27、of all,by providing all children with fundamental skills and knowledge, a common core curriculumwould help ensure that our children grow up to become reasonably informed, productivemembers of society. in addition, a common core curriculum would provide a predictablefoundation upon which college admi
28、nistrators and faculty could more easily build curricula andselect course materials for freshmen that are neither below nor above their level of educationalexperience. finally, a core curriculum would ensure that all school-children are taught corevalues upon which any democratic society depends to
29、thrive, and even survive-values suchas tolerance of others with different viewpoints, and respect for others.however, a common curriculum that is also an exclusive one would pose certain problems,which might outweigh the benefits, noted above. first of all, on what basis would certaincourse work be
30、included or excluded, and who would be the final decision- maker? in alllikelihood these decisions would be in the hands of federal legislators and regulators, who arelikely to have their own quirky notions of what should and should not be taught tochildren-notions that may or may not reflect those
31、of most communities, schools, or parents.besides, government officials are notoriously susceptible to influence-peddling by lobbyistswho do not have the best interests of societys children in mind.secondly, an official, federally sanctioned curriculum would facilitate the dissemination(散布,傳播) of pro
32、paganda and other dogma which because of its biased and one-sided nature undermines the very purpose of true education: to enlighten. i can easily foresee the banning of certain text books, programs, and websites which provide information and perspectives that the government might wish to suppress-a
33、s some sort of threat to its authority and power.although this scenario might seem far-fetched, these sorts of concerns are being raisedalready at the state level. thirdly, the inflexible nature of a uniform national curriculum would preclude the inclusion of programs, courses, and materials that ar
34、e primarily of regional or local significance. for example, california requires children at certain grade levels to learn about the history of particular ethnic groups who make up the states diverse population. a national curriculum might not allow for this feature, and californias youngsters would
35、be worse off as a result of their ignorance about the traditions, values, and cultural contributions of all the people whose citizenship they share.finally, it seems to me that imposing a uniform national curriculum would serve toundermine the authority of parents over their own children, to even a
36、greater extent thanuniform state laws currently do. admittedly, laws requiring parents to ensure that their childrenreceive an education that meets certain minimum standards are well-justified, for the reasonsmentioned earlier. however, when such standards are imposed by the state rather than at the
37、community level parents are left with far less power to participate meaningfully in thedecision-making process. this problem would only be exacerbated were these decisions leftexclusively to federal regulators.in the final analysis, homogenization of elementary and secondary education would amountto
38、 a double-edged sword. while it would serve as an insurance policy against a futurepopulated with illiterates and ignoramuses, at the same time it might serve to obliterate culturaldiversity and tradition. the optimal federal approach, in my view, is a balanced one thatimposes a basic curriculum yet
39、 leaves the rest up to each state-or better yet, to eachcommunity.issue 4the video camera provides such an accurate and convincing record of contemporary life thatit has become a more important form of documentation than written records.according to the speaker, the video recording is a more importa
40、nt means of document hagcontemporary life than a written record because video recordings are more accurate andconvincing. although i agree that a video provides a more objective and accurate record of anevents spatial aspects, there is far more to document ha life than what we see and hear. thusthe
41、speaker overstates the comparative significance of video as a documentary tool.for the purpose of documenting temporal, spatial events and experiences, i agree that avideo record is usually more accurate and more convincing than a written record. it isimpossible for anyone, no matter how keen an obs
42、erver and skilled a journalist, to recount hacomplete and objective detail such events as the winning touchdown at the super bowl, aballanchine ballet, the tournament of roses parade, or the scene at the intersection offlorence and normandy streets during the 1992 los angeles riots. yet these are im
43、portantevents in contemporary life the sort of events we might put ha a time capsule for the purposeof capturing our life and times at the turn of this millennium.the growing documentary role of video is not limited to seminal events like those describedabove. video surveillance cameras are objectiv
44、e witnesses with perfect memories. thus theycan play a vital evidentiary role in legal proceedings-such as those involving robbery, drugtrafficking, police misconduct, motor vehicle violations, and even malpractice in a hospitaloperating room. indeed, whenever moving images are central to an event t
45、he video camera issuperior to the written word. a written description of a hurricane, tornado, or volcanic eruptioncannot convey its immediate power and awesome nature like a video record. a diary entrycannot replay that wedding reception, dance recital, or surprise birthday party as accuratelyor ob
46、jectively as a video record. and a real estate brochure cannot inform about the lighting,spaciousness, or general ambiance of a featured property nearly as effectively as a video.nonetheless, for certain other purposes written records are advantageous to and moreappropriate than video records. for e
47、xample, certain legal matters are best left to writtendocumentation: video is of no practical use ha documenting the terms of a complex contractualagreement, an incorporation, or the establishment of a trust. and video is of little use when itcomes to documenting a persons subjective state of mind,
48、impressions, or reflections of anevent or experience. indeed, to the extent that personal interpretation adds dimension andrichness to the record, written documentation is actually more important than video.finally, a video record is of no use in documenting statistical or other quantitative informa
49、tion.returning to the riot example mentioned earlier, imagine relying on a video to document thefinancial loss to store owners, the number of police and firefighters involved, and so forth.complete and accurate video documentation of such information would require video camerasat every street corner
50、 and in every aisle of every store.in sum, the speakers claim overstates the importance of video records, at least to someextent. when it comes to capturing, storing, and recalling temporal, spatial events, videorecords are inherently more objective, accurate, and complete. however, what we viewthro
51、ugh a camera lens provides only one dimension of our life and times; writtendocumentation will always be needed to quantify, demystify, and provide meaning to the worldaround us.issue 5it is often necessary, even desirable, for political leaders to withhold information from thepublic.i agree with th
52、e speaker that it is sometimes necessary, and even desirable, for politicalleaders to withhold information from the public. a contrary view would reveal a naivetd aboutthe inherent nature of public politics, and about the sorts of compromises on the part ofwell-intentioned political leaders necessar
53、y in order to further the publics ultmaate interests.nevertheless, we must not allow our political leaders undue freedom to with-hold information,otherwise, we risk sanctioning demagoguery and undermining the philosophical underpinningsof any democratic society.one reason for my fundamental agreemen
54、t with the speaker is that in order to gain theopportunity for effective public leadership, a would-be leader must fzrst gain and maintainpolitical power. in the game of politics, complete forthrightness is a sign of vulnerability andnaivete, neither of which earn a politician respect among his or h
55、er opponents, and whichthose opponents will use to every advantage to defeat the politician. in my observation somemeasure of pandering to the electorate is necessary to gain and maintain political leadership.for example, were all politicians to fully disclose every personal foibles, character flaw,
56、 anddetail concerning personal life, few honest politicians would ever by elected. while this viewmight seem cynical, personal scandals have in fact proven the undoing of many a politicalcareer; thus i think this view is realistic.another reason why i essentially agree with the speaker is that fully
57、 disclosing to the publiccertain types of information would threaten public safety and perhaps even national security.for example, if the president were to disclose the governments strategies for thwartingspecific plans of an international terrorist or a drug trafficker, those strategies would surel
58、y fail,and the publics health and safety would be compromised as a result. withholding informationmight also be necessary to avoid public panic. while such cases are rare, they do occuroccasionally. for example, during the first few hours of the new millennium the u.s.pentagons missile defense system experienced a y2k- related malfunction. this fact waswithheld from the public until later in the day, once the problem had been solved;
溫馨提示
- 1. 本站所有資源如無特殊說明,都需要本地電腦安裝OFFICE2007和PDF閱讀器。圖紙軟件為CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.壓縮文件請下載最新的WinRAR軟件解壓。
- 2. 本站的文檔不包含任何第三方提供的附件圖紙等,如果需要附件,請聯(lián)系上傳者。文件的所有權(quán)益歸上傳用戶所有。
- 3. 本站RAR壓縮包中若帶圖紙,網(wǎng)頁內(nèi)容里面會有圖紙預(yù)覽,若沒有圖紙預(yù)覽就沒有圖紙。
- 4. 未經(jīng)權(quán)益所有人同意不得將文件中的內(nèi)容挪作商業(yè)或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文庫網(wǎng)僅提供信息存儲空間,僅對用戶上傳內(nèi)容的表現(xiàn)方式做保護處理,對用戶上傳分享的文檔內(nèi)容本身不做任何修改或編輯,并不能對任何下載內(nèi)容負(fù)責(zé)。
- 6. 下載文件中如有侵權(quán)或不適當(dāng)內(nèi)容,請與我們聯(lián)系,我們立即糾正。
- 7. 本站不保證下載資源的準(zhǔn)確性、安全性和完整性, 同時也不承擔(dān)用戶因使用這些下載資源對自己和他人造成任何形式的傷害或損失。
最新文檔
- 2024年采購合同變更協(xié)議
- 審計業(yè)務(wù)約定書模板
- 私人購房合同模板
- 深圳市房地產(chǎn)出租合同書
- 專業(yè)保證擔(dān)保合同大全
- 電視廣告代理權(quán)協(xié)議
- 住宅拆遷協(xié)議書
- 會計師會議協(xié)議書
- 2024版自愿離婚協(xié)議書寫作要點
- 西安市房地產(chǎn)轉(zhuǎn)讓合同-合同范本
- 互聯(lián)網(wǎng)發(fā)展靠創(chuàng)新 課件 2024-2025學(xué)年人教版(2024)初中信息科技七年級全一冊
- 患者溝通技巧
- 廣告?zhèn)惱韱栴}
- 十歲生日模板
- 期中檢測卷(試題)-2024-2025學(xué)年北師大版五年級上冊數(shù)學(xué)
- 九宮數(shù)獨200題(附答案全)
- 護士延續(xù)注冊體檢表
- MOOC 高級綜合英語-北京交通大學(xué) 中國大學(xué)慕課答案
- 2023年中國船級社人才招聘筆試參考題庫附帶答案詳解
- 14S501-1 球墨鑄鐵單層井蓋及踏步施工
- 【原創(chuàng)】《基于地理實踐力培養(yǎng)的校本課程開發(fā)研究》中期報告
評論
0/150
提交評論